When “ER” ended in 2009, Noah Wyle and television producers, R. Scott Gemmill & John Welles developed a concept of reviving the late Michael Crichton’s medical drama upon receiving positive direct messages and comments by fans who grew up watching the show were inspired to become real life doctors as well as sharing their thoughts on enduring the COVID-19 pandemic. Noah and the producers brainstormed ideas on a spin-off centering on Dr. John Carter. Due to legal issues under Michael‘s estate, the spin-off’s scrapped in favor of an original series as a spiritual successor to ER titled, “The Pitt.”
Clocking in for a 15-hour shift of the titular medical center, experienced physician, Michael “Robby” Robinavitch leads a team of doctors and medical students to cure patients under severe conditions. Robby and his team endure both professional and personal up-and-downs doing whatever they can to save many people as much as they can in a 15-hour shift.
The Pitt’s first season officially streamed in 2025 (same year Daredevil: Born Again streamed) on HBO Max. It received massive praise from critics and streamers alike. The Pitt won a Golden Globe and Emmy for “Outstanding Drama Series.” Noah Wyle also won a Golden Globe and Emmy for “Best Actor in a Drama Series.” All episodes of Season 2 are also available. Season 3 will stream on January, 2027. Now that it’s Awards Season, I wanna share my opinion on The Pitt’s first season. See if it’s worth your spare time.
Today’s review contains no SPOILERS. I’m giving newcomers a chance to see this award-winning series.
Healthy & Unhealthy Aspects
Healthy: Noah Wyle, Fiona Dourif, Patrick Ball, Taylor Dearden, Katherine LaNasa, Isa Briones, Gerran Howell & Taylor Dearden all did a fantastic job for their respective performances.
R. Scott Gemmill mapped out all 15 episodes as a cohesive storyline. Plus, he served as an executive producer along with Mr. Wyle & John Welles.
Practical Effects were heavily involved staging surgical procedures.
High Quality Production Value. The entire emergency room’s one big set piece. No CGI present.
Chemistry between Robby and his medical team serves as the main highlight.
Although they lack focus, some patients have interesting backgrounds. Outcomes may vary.
Labeled as a serious drama, there are some Funny Moments that made me chuckle. Especially, a running gag involving one character getting his scrubs messy.
Pacing felt stable. My eyes were glued to the screen.
Like “24,” each episode is set in real time one hour per episode. A 15-hour shift from 7:00 AM-9:00 PM.
The show is medically accurate. You can tell the writers really did their homework. I’ll let you in on a warning. If you can’t handle graphic surgery, it may turn you off. Sixth episode made me cover my groin. Why? Because one of the patients had to be painfully treated by repositioning a testicle. Thank goodness it’s shown offscreen. If you have the guts to bingewatch all 15 episodes, be prepared.
Besides medical accuracy, working as a doctor in a medical center is unpredictable. Some patients make it out or not. There’s a crucial plot point close to the last few episodes.
Shocking Moments will make you gasp. I felt the tension.
Most of the doctors have interesting backgrounds outside the workplace.
Character Development involving Robby and his crew.
Primary Themes are Trauma, Trust, Teamwork & Loss. Each one’s handled maturely.
Fun Facts
- For those who don’t know, Fiona Dourif is actually Brad Dourif’s real life daughter. That’s right, Chucky’s daughter caught the acting bug. She’s also known for her role as Nica Pierce in the Chucky franchise.
- Speaking of talking dolls, Brad Dourif makes a guest appearance in a later episode.
- The Pitt’s a nickname for the “Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center.“
Random Thoughts
- I’ve only watched ER’s pilot episode. I’m familiar with the show, but not a mega fan.
- Cassie McKay is my favorite character.
Unhealthy: Cinematography can be janky at times.
The Final Verdict: A-
Despite one drawback, I really enjoyed The Pitt’s first season. Is it definitely worth your spare time? Heck yes. If you’re new to the series, I highly recommend it. Which award-winning series should I watch and review next? Please leave a comment and don’t forget to subscribe.




